I just finished the 20/20 on Matthew Shepard. It had been sitting on my TiVo for nearly 2 weeks as I avoided it. I thought I had to watch it in order to form an opinion, but I knew I'd be annoyed by it, as much for the formulaic network garbage as for the particular content of this episode. It lived up to and exceeded expectations. I think the network did what networks do, sensationalize and pander to the mood of the moment to get a big audience. I just hate that America watches it!
So, as to content, click here to see what Judy Shepherd has to say, and here for GLAAD's take on the questions that should have been asked. Both are worth a read. Andrew Sullivan should have been identified as a conservative instead of just a "prominent gay advocate." He is a prominent gay advocate, but far from the generic brand. The show used innuendo and interviews of self-confessed liars and killers to try to say that it wasn't a hate crime; I still belive it was, the moral values crowd never did. This certainly plays to them. What I saw in Aaron McKinney and Russell Henderson were a couple of lying thugs covering their butts.
My biggest reaction though is to note that these days homophobes are getting away with denying that they have any antipathy to gay people at all. Aaron McKinney saying that he had gay friends. Yeah right. Why didn't 20/20 interview one? His definition of "friend" is he's seen one around and not beat him up! It's like racists saying they have black friends because they like the black woman who waits on them at Waffle House. That's so broad a definition of friend as to be meaningless.
Now we have Jerry Falwell and James Dobson saying that they have no animosity towards gay people. At first I thought this a good thing: they've been forced by the success of the lesbian and gay civil rights movement to hide their homophobia. But now it worries me. What they're really doing is cloaking their homo hatred in tolerance and compassion. Others are taking their lead. Many of them voted for the anti-gay marriage amendments, comfortable that they're still tolerant and compassionate. For all the complaints about political correctness, it seems to me the Right has learned to twist it so that it works well as a tool to preserve and protect their intolerance and bigotry.
UPDATE -- Frank Rich had a great colmn in the New York Times on Sunday commenting on the pandering to the right that network television news is doing these days. The 20/20 Matthew Shepard piece was a case in point. blogACTIVE applauds him for it.